Market Manipulation

Bates assisted a client in proactively investigating an issue identified by their internal controls. Our staff and experts completed a comprehensive review of trading activity over a multi-year period for an equity security traded on both U.S. and International exchanges. Bates collected and modeled detailed order book information to evaluate the following characteristics related to the market microstructure of trading in the security across both exchanges: 

• Cancellation activity
• Trade-to-order volume
• Short bursts of sell initiated volume, pre-market selling activity versus subsequent trading
• Time to cancel
• Concentration and pattern of cancelled orders on particular days/times
• Execution proximity to best bid/offer
• Order size
• Other factors

These same characteristics were evaluated for shifts in market dynamics over time and in comparison to trading on the same exchanges in peer company securities while also noting differences/similarities in trading across the two exchanges. The price impact of potentially noneconomic trading was established, and a formal report was submitted, as well as several reports rebutting the findings of the regulator, culminating in testimony by a Bates expert before the regulator.

Bates experts were called upon to evaluate the conduct of a team of traders within a large global financial institution for a variety of issues, including trading ahead of client orders, inappropriate trade mark up, indications of market manipulation or attempted manipulation, and round-trip trading—in the latter two areas we also considered the behavior and involvement of traders from other major financial institutions. The analysis required a detailed investigation of daily trading, spreads, and quotations on major currencies and currency derivatives, as well as interviews and communication reviews of the alleged involved parties.  The report prepared by Bates identified significant failures in the institution’s internal supervisory and control processes and was relied upon in subsequent litigation.

In a recent investigation, Bates was asked to assess the trading of an individual who had accumulated an ownership interest in multiple penny stocks as payment for consulting services rendered. This individual was then alleged to have used both his accumulated ownership and access to company insider information to conduct a classic “pump & dump” of the stock. Bates performed a detailed quantitative assessment of his trading using both publicly available data and Blue Sheets, as well as a qualitative assessment to establish interrelationships between parties via phone records, text message exchanges, and emails. Bates provided detailed timelines of trading activity that included news events, volume, intraday pricing, short interest, and other relevant characteristics. We prepared interactive models showing the relationships between parties, their trading behavior versus the rest of the market, and other demonstratives. We then estimated potential damages following a modified share price inflation methodology. As a result of the work Bates performed, additional potential market manipulators were identified.

On a criminal pump & dump matter, Bates performed the full range of analyses listed above in addition to preparing demonstratives specifically concerning wash or matched trading. During the course of performing our analysis, Bates was informed that several of the alleged manipulators pled not guilty on the basis that they were unaware that the manipulation was taking place. Bates assessed their trading records, Blue Sheet data, and communication records to establish that, at a minimum, they had knowingly participated in wash or matched trading during the manipulated period.